Background Aum Shinrikyo pioneered the first impactful domestic mass-application of a nerve-agent since its inception in warfare. Approximately 10% of responders and 23% of hospital staff reported symptoms of secondary exposure, fuelling concerns about the United Kingdom response. Secondary exposure risks in chemical incidents continues across developed countries in lesser circumstances.
Legislation and guidance for emergency responders in specialist situations further compounds complexity of responding in challenging environments. The Human Rights Act alongside modern western medico-legal philosophy encourages everything possible to preserve life. Conversely, this must be balanced against the risks to rescuers.
Specialist units have been established ensuring pre-hospital responders are protected while delivering care. In England and Wales, this is through Hazardous Area Response Teams (HART).
These teams deliver Advanced Life Support (ALS) in challenging environments. However, the extent to which Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) affects the ability to deliver clinical interventions is not truly tested alongside human factors.
Methods An electronic database search for articles was undertaken, using a PRISMA framework for reporting, individual articles were then assessed using Critical Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) checklists before common themes were extrapolated using mixed methods to analyse the impact of PPE on clinical skills and human factors.
Results 14 articles were found for full review, being a mix of systematic reviews (n=2), simulative studies (n=11) and a masters thesis (n=1). Data was heterogenous with articles measuring specific skills including intubation, cannulation and chest compression quality with others taking a qualitative approach to impedance of skills i.e. effects on dexterity. Major flaws were identified in most of the literature.
Conclusion Findings from this review reveal PPE delays and affects clinical care — impacting human factors and exacerbating the standard of care delivered failing below normal standards. This needs full assessment and further research to inform guidance for operatives in this environment.